MLB The Show has cemented its reputation as the premier baseball simulation, and one of the most exciting aspects of Diamond Dynasty each year is the release of the “Finest” series. In 2025, the craze continues with a fresh drop of Finest cards, featuring roughly 50 new items that highlight the top MLB stars of the season. These cards represent the pinnacle of in-game talent, offering exceptional stats, unique ratings, and gameplay potential that can dramatically enhance your Diamond Dynasty roster.

In this guide, we break down the ten best Finest cards in MLB The Show 25, analyzing their stats, gameplay advantages, and how they can elevate your team in both offense and defense. Whether you are a seasoned Diamond Dynasty player or just starting to MLB The Show 25 Stubs build your elite lineup, knowing which Finest cards deliver the most value is essential.

What Makes a Finest Card Special?

Finest cards are not just regular high-rated cards. They combine several elements that make them game-changing:

Elite Ratings: Finest cards feature above-average stats across the board, often with power, contact, and speed bonuses for hitters, and velocity, control, and stamina boosts for pitchers.

Signature Abilities: Many Finest cards come with unique badges or abilities that are only available to select cards in the series, giving them special in-game advantages.

Meta Influence: Finest cards are generally designed to be competitive at the highest levels, making them especially valuable in online modes like Ranked Seasons or Battle Royale.

Historical Current Stardom: The cards spotlight top performers from the MLB season, blending star power with high gameplay impact.

With these attributes, Finest cards are not just collector items—they are gameplay assets that can tilt a matchup in your favor.

Top 10 Finest Cards in MLB The Show 25
1. Shohei Ohtani – Pitcher/Designated Hitter

Ohtani remains a dual-threat in the digital world just as in real life. His Finest card offers:

Elite velocity and secondary pitches as a pitcher

High contact, power, and speed ratings as a hitter

Unique ability to change the game on both sides of the ball

This card is particularly valuable for players who want a two-way strategy or need a game-changer in clutch moments.

2. Aaron Judge – Outfielder

Judge's Finest card capitalizes on his home run potential:

Maxed-out power ratings

Above-average contact and vision

Exceptional arm strength for right field

In Diamond Dynasty, Judge is perfect for both starting lineups and late-game pinch-hitting situations.

3. Mookie Betts – Outfielder

Betts continues to be a top-tier card for speed and defensive coverage:

Elite fielding ratings, including range and reaction

High contact and contact plus ability to spray the ball

Speed that allows for both base-stealing and chasing down deep hits

He is invaluable for players looking to dominate on defense and create scoring opportunities on the base paths.

4. José Ramírez – Third Baseman

Ramírez combines power and consistency:

Balanced contact and power ratings

Above-average speed for extra bases

Strong fielding and throwing ratings at third base

His versatility makes him a solid anchor in your infield lineup, capable of both offensive production and defensive reliability.

5. Trea Turner – Shortstop

Turner's Finest card is all about speed and agility:

Elite speed and base-stealing capability

Excellent contact and situational hitting stats

Strong defensive ratings at shortstop

Perfect for players who want a dynamic presence up the middle, Turner can create runs with minimal opportunities and prevent hits on defense.

6. Juan Soto – Outfielder

Soto's Finest card is designed for the plate discipline elite:

High contact, vision, and patience ratings

Above-average power and ability to drive the ball

Solid defensive stats for a left fielder

Soto's ability to get on base consistently makes him a strategic asset for run creation.

7. Gerrit Cole – Starting Pitcher

Cole's Finest card excels on the mound:

Maximum fastball velocity and effective secondary pitches

High control and stamina ratings

Ability to dominate strikeouts and limit walks

This card is ideal for players building a rotation to shut down opponents in ranked or competitive modes.

8. Bryce Harper – Outfielder

Harper's Finest card emphasizes slugging and versatility:

Above-average contact and power

Excellent clutch ratings and situational hitting stats

Solid fielding and arm strength

Harper provides consistent production at multiple positions, making him a flexible piece in any lineup.

9. Mike Trout – Center Fielder

Trout's Finest card continues to be a cornerstone:

Elite contact, power, and speed ratings

Superb defensive coverage in center field

Balanced base running and situational awareness

Trout is valuable both offensively and defensively, giving players a reliable all-around star.

10. Freddie Freeman – First Baseman

Freeman's Finest card blends power with plate discipline:

Above-average contact and power

Solid vision and situational hitting stats

Strong defensive reliability at first base

Freeman is particularly effective in the heart of the lineup, providing consistent RBI production and defensive stability.

Strategies for Using Finest Cards

Balance Your Lineup: Combine power hitters, contact specialists, and speedsters to create a versatile offense.

Prioritize Defense: While Finest cards excel offensively, don't overlook fielding and arm strength. Defensive plays win tight games.

Optimize Pitching: Use cards like Cole and Ohtani to control high-pressure innings and preserve bullpen stamina.

Consider Base Running: Speed and stealing ability, particularly from Turner and Betts, can be leveraged to apply constant pressure on opponents.

Rotate Effectively: Bench some Finest hitters for late-game scenarios to maintain stamina and maximize clutch performance.

Final Thoughts

MLB The Show 25's 2025 Finest collection is a must-have for any serious Diamond Dynasty player. Featuring roughly 50 new cards, these items highlight the top MLB talent of the season and provide game-changing abilities on both offense and defense. The ten cards listed above represent the best of the best, offering a blend of power, speed, defense, and strategic versatility.

Whether you are looking to build the ultimate offensive machine, dominate on defense, or simply collect the most iconic MLB stars, the Finest series provides unmatched opportunities. By integrating these top cards into your lineup and leveraging their unique skills, you can take your Diamond Dynasty gameplay to the next level, compete at the highest tiers,buy MLB Stubs and enjoy the full thrill of MLB The Show 25.